Simon's Legal Resources

(Ontario/Canada)

HOME / About / Democracy, Law and Duty / Testimonials / Essays / Link Policy / Help! / Opinion Intake / Conditions of Use

TOPICS


JR - AAR (7)

. Sherwin v. Blunt

In Sherwin v. Blunt (Div Ct, 2026) the Divisional Court allowed a complainant's JR, this brought when "the Integrity Commissioner informed Mr. Sherwin that she was declining his request for an investigation of the complaints on the basis that she lacked jurisdiction".

Here the court notes that the "Integrity Commissioner’s decision is bereft of any explanation for how she arrived at the conclusion that she lacked jurisdiction", and considers both 'adequacy of reasons' and adequate alternative remedy (AAR) arguments in this context:
[32] .... The issues raised by this judicial review focus on the decision that the Respondent lacked jurisdiction and the adequacy of those reasons.

....

[38] On its face and on a plain reading, the Integrity Commissioner’s decision is bereft of any explanation for how she arrived at the conclusion that she lacked jurisdiction. It might be argued that perhaps she meant that she lacked jurisdiction because there were alternate procedures available; however, that is not clear from her decision and does not assist for reasons that follow.

[39] The Integrity Commissioner directed the Applicant to communicate with Township legal counsel on four of the five complaints. That is not an alternate procedure under other legislation or Municipal policy. There is no legislation that directs a complainant in respect of an integrity complaint to deal directly with legal counsel for the alleged violator, nor is there any reference in her decision to any municipal policy that so directs. Certainly, the Respondent made no mention of such legislation or Municipal policy in her decision, and counsel could not identify same.

[40] The Respondent’s direction to the Applicant to raise the issues in his complaint with the Township’s legal counsel is not an ‘alternate procedure’ contemplated by the Code of Conduct policy. Respondent’s counsel on this judicial review was unable to explain how “go see the lawyer” is an alternate procedure under legislation or the Township’s policy.

[41] With respect to the direction that the zoning complaint (complaint #4) can and should be addressed through the OLT appeal, that direction misapprehends the scope of the OLT proceeding which cannot and does not address the ethical issues raised by the Applicant concerning the conduct of the mayor and councillors. The OLT hearing looks at the proposed rezoning request on its merits. It is a hearing de novo. Evidence that councillors acted in bad faith or discriminated against the Applicant based on his place of origin is irrelevant. That is “water under the bridge”. The OLT does not adjudicate on propriety of the conduct of municipal councillors; rather, it looks at the merit of the requested rezoning afresh with no regard for whether councillors adhered to their Code of Conduct.

[42] Thus, the OLT appeal will address whether the rezoning should be granted but does not address whether the complaints made by the Applicant that the mayor and councillors breached the Code of Conduct are meritorious. The OLT is not, in this sense, an alternate process to address the issues raised by the complaint. Put another way, the OLT appeal will deal with the result of the impugned conduct, – denial of the rezoning application, but will not address the allegations of misconduct by the mayor and councillors that preceded and informed that result.

[43] In these circumstances, the Integrity Commissioner’s directions to pursue discussions with the Township’s lawyer and that the OLT proceeding will address the complaint made are unreasonable and do not justify her decision to decline jurisdiction.

[44] Further, the failure to provide any reasons that explain how she arrived at the conclusion that she lacked jurisdiction is unreasonable.
. West Carleton Community Alliance v. City of Ottawa

In West Carleton Community Alliance v. City of Ottawa (Div Ct, 2026) the Divisional Court dismissed a JR, this brought against an Ottawa zoning by-law.

Here the court considers the conflicts that arise where the applicant seeks by JR to quash a municipal bylaw (under the JRPA in the Divisional Court), but also to quash the bylaw under MA s.273 ['Application to quash by-law'] - which should be brought in the Superior Court:
[39] The jurisdictional issue arises because the applicant has brought an application for judicial review but has also asked, in the alternative, for relief under s. 273 of the Municipal Act, 2001. The Divisional Court has jurisdiction to quash the Zoning By-law, as set out in s. 2(1) of the Judicial Review Procedure Act, R.S.O. 1990, c J.1. However, if the applicant wanted to proceed under s. 273 of the Municipal Act, 2001, it had to bring its application in the Superior Court, not the Divisional Court. It cannot be addressed, as suggested, in the alternative.

[40] This Court may exercise its discretion not to hear the judicial review because the applicant could have proceeded under s. 273: Yatar v. TD Insurance Meloche Monnex, 2024 SCC 8, 489 D.L.R. (4th) 181, at paras. 51 and 54. Several factors inform the question of whether that alternative process is adequate in this case: Yatar, at para. 64, citing Strickland v. Canada (Attorney General), 2015 SCC 37, [2015] 2 S.C.R. 713, at para. 43. We have not been asked to dismiss this application in favour of that alternative process and, having considered the factors relevant to the exercise of our discretion, we would not do so. In the circumstances of this case, it is appropriate to proceed with the judicial review application, which can fully and efficiently address the issues raised.



CC0

Unless authorship is otherwise stated or obvious from the context, all
written materials in this website were created by Simon Shields, who
waives all of his copyright and related or neighboring rights to this
Isthatlegal.ca webpage. Note in particular that this waiver only applies to
Simon's material, as copyright in statutory/regulatory materials and
case extracts were never his to give away.




Last modified: 02-10-26
By: admin