Simon's Legal Resources

(Ontario/Canada)

HOME / About / Democracy, Law and Duty / Testimonials / Essays / Link Policy / Help! / Opinion Intake / Conditions of Use

TOPICS


JR - Prematurity (7)

. AB v. Law Society of Ontario

In AB v. Law Society of Ontario (Div Ct, 2026) the Divisional Court dismissed a JR, this brought against "an interlocutory decision of the [SS: Law Society] Tribunal" which "dismissed the applicant’s motion seeking a stay of proceedings".

Here the court applies the doctrine of JR 'exhaustion' (here styled as 'prematurity'):
Prematurity

[10] The Law Society raised a preliminary issue in this court, which was that the application for judicial review should be dismissed as premature.

[11] We agree with the Law Society’s submission that, in accordance with longstanding jurisprudence, the court will refrain from interfering in ongoing tribunal proceedings absent exceptional circumstances.

[12] C.B. Powell Limited v. Canada (Border Services Agency), 2010 FCA 61, at para. 30, sets out the rule as applied in this court: “The normal rule is that parties can proceed to the court system only after all adequate remedial recourses in the administrative process have been exhausted….[A]bsent exceptional circumstances, those who are dissatisfied with some matter arising in the ongoing administrative process must pursue all effective remedies that are available within that process; only when the administrative process has finished or when the administrative process affords no effective remedy can they proceed to court.” In Awada v. Allstate, 2021 ONSC 8108, D.L. Corbett J. noted at para. 9 that the principle of non-interference in the course of administrative proceedings is “scrupulously” followed in this court.

[13] Very few circumstances qualify as exceptional for the purpose of the test. As set out in C.B. Powell at para. 33: “Concerns about procedural fairness or bias, the presence of an important legal or constitutional issue, or the fact that all parties have consented to early recourse to the courts are not exceptional circumstances allowing parties to bypass an administrative process, as long as that process allows the issues to be raised and an effective remedy to be granted.”
. El Kabbani v. Ontario College of Pharmacists [purpose of prematurity doctrine]

In El Kabbani v. Ontario College of Pharmacists (Div Ct, 2026) the Divisional Court granted the College's motion to quash a JR, here brought against the College decision to commence "an investigation into the conduct of the four pharmacists".

Here the court considers the court-efficiency purpose of the prematurity doctrine:
[12] The prematurity principle “is not simply a dry, technical rule”: Muslim Assn of Canada v. Canada (Attorney General), 2023 ONSC 5171, 168 O.R. (3d) 294, at para. 66. The reasons for the rule were explained in C.B. Powell Limited, at para. 32:
This prevents fragmentation of the administrative process and piecemeal court proceedings, eliminates the large costs and delays associated with premature forays to court and avoids the waste associated with hearing an interlocutory judicial review when the applicant for judicial review may succeed at the end of the administrative process anyway. Further, only at the end of the administrative process will a reviewing court have all of the administrative decision-maker’s findings; these findings may be suffused with expertise, legitimate policy judgments and valuable regulatory experience. Finally, this approach is consistent with and supports the concept of judicial respect for administrative decision-makers who, like judges, have decision-making responsibilities to discharge. [Citations omitted].
See also College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario v. Kilian, 2024 ONCA 52, at para. 29; Volochay, at para. 69.
. Caledon Residences Inc. v. Ontario Land Tribunal

In Caledon Residences Inc. v. Ontario Land Tribunal (Ont Div Ct, 2025) the Ontario Divisional Court dismissed a JR, here brought against "the decision of the Ontario Land Tribunal".

The central issue here was whether the JR applicant should instead have sought a statutory appeal (which required leave), and that the JR was therefore premature:
[3] For the reasons set out below, the application is dismissed. Section 24(1) of OLTA indicates a clear legislative intention to subject the Tribunal’s decisions on questions of law to a requirement that leave be sought. ....

[4] Judicial review in these circumstances would undermine the Legislature’s choice to subject questions of law to a leave motion. The statutory appeal mechanism is a meaningful and adequate means to challenge decisions on questions of law that are incorrect or were taken in a way that was procedurally unfair: Humberplex Developments Inc. v. Ontario (AG), 2024 ONSC 2335 (Div Ct.).

....

Issue 1. Is Judicial Review appropriate or suitable in this case?

[18] Sunshine Group submits that this court should decline to hear CRI’s application for judicial review because the statutory appeal mechanism, which is restricted to questions of law, requires potential appellants to seek leave to appeal. Section 24 (1) of the Ontario Land Tribunal Act, 2021, c 4, Sch 6 (“OLTA”) provides:
24 (1) Unless another Act specifies otherwise, an order or decision of the Tribunal may be appealed to the Divisional Court, with leave of that court on motion in accordance with subsection (3), but only on a question of law.
[19] The applicant submitted that it did not bring a motion for leave to appeal because it did not think it met the leave criterion requiring that the question be of sufficient general or public importance to merit the attention of the court. The deadline has passed to seek leave to appeal under subrule 61.03 (1)(b) of the Rules of Civil Procedure, RRO 1990, Reg 194. A motion for an extension of time remains available to CRI under rules 2.03 and 3.02. Sunshine Group submits that while it believes that the “general or public importance” criteria is met, the test for leave is not met with respect to the merits of the appeal and there is no reason to doubt the correctness of the decision.

....

Analysis

[20] In Yatar v TD Insurance Meloche Monnex, 2024 SCC 8 at para.54, the Supreme Court of Canada emphasized that reviewing courts are required to begin their inquiry by determining whether to exercise their discretion to judicially review a decision. CRI’s application for judicial review is based solely on whether there was a breach of procedural fairness. Since procedural fairness is a legal standard, the assessment of whether an administrative decision-maker complied with this duty is a question of law: Law Society of Saskatchewan v. Abrametz, 2022 SCC 29 at paras. 30; Patton v. Aviva Insurance Co. of Canada, 2025 ONSC 4234 at para. 35 (Div. Ct.); Shapiro v. Swingler, 2021 ONSC 6191, at paras. 16 and 25 (Div. Ct.); 2541005 Ontario Ltd. v. Oro-Medonte (Township), 2023 ONSC 5569 at para. 35 (Div. Ct.).

[21] Section 24(1) of OLTA indicates a clear legislative intention to subject the Tribunal’s decisions on questions of law to a requirement that leave be sought. Allowing judicial review in these circumstances would undermine the Legislature’s choice to subject questions of law to a leave motion. In Humberplex Developments Inc. v. Ontario (AG), 2024 ONSC 2335 (Div Ct.) the court held that questions of procedural fairness raised in an application for judicial review were more appropriately addressed in the motion for leave to appeal and appeal and that they provide an adequate alternative remedy that is consistent with the applicable statutory scheme, under which applicants can address questions of law (including procedural fairness) in the context of an appeal. The statutory appeal mechanism is a meaningful and adequate means to challenge decisions on questions of law that are incorrect or were taken in a way that was procedurally unfair.

[22] Accordingly, I would decline to exercise my discretion to hear CRI’s application for judicial review.



CC0

Unless authorship is otherwise stated or obvious from the context, all
written materials in this website were created by Simon Shields, who
waives all of his copyright and related or neighboring rights to this
Isthatlegal.ca webpage. Note in particular that this waiver only applies to
Simon's material, as copyright in statutory/regulatory materials and
case extracts were never his to give away.




Last modified: 21-10-26
By: admin