|
Administrative - Administrative Penalties (2). Sepasi v. Foster
In Sepasi v. Foster (Div Ct, 2026) the Divisional Court considered a landlord's RTA s.210 appeal, this where the LTB "ordered a rent abatement of $3,939.54 and imposed a $20,000.00 administrative penalty", these related to illegal entries.
Here the court extensively considers the 'administrative fine' provisions of the RTA [s.31(1)(d)], and finds that there was a "duty on the Board to make inquiries about the appellant’s ability to pay a fine before imposing one and heard submissions from the parties on this issue":C. The Administrative Fine
(i) Overview
[40] The Member imposed an administrative fine of $20,000.00 on the basis that the appellant had shown a blatant disregard for the RTA and the tenant’s right to its protections. He found the fact that the appellant had falsely told the police that the respondent had been evicted by the Board to be a “particularly shocking disregard for the Board’s processes or the Tenant’s interests.”
[41] The appellant has raised various issues with respect to the fine, all of which involve disputes with the factual findings made by the Member. On particular significance to the appellant is evidence that notes from a police officer are inconsistent with the respondent’s testimony that he had falsely told the police that she had been evicted. The appellant submits that the Member erred by ignoring the police notes, which he characterized as “the only objective evidence on file.” The appellant’s submissions do not raise questions of law, so cannot form a basis for setting aside the fine. In any event, the Member was entitled to accept the respondent’s sworn testimony over the police notes.
[42] During the hearing of the appeal, I raised the issue of whether there was any duty on the Board to make inquiries about the appellant’s ability to pay a fine before imposing one and heard submissions from the parties on this issue. Counsel for the Board advised me that they were not aware of any caselaw on this issue and there is nothing in the RTA or the Board’s Interpretation Guidelines which address this.
[43] For the reasons that follow, I have concluded that the Board must address the issue of an individual’s ability to pay before imposing an administrative fine, at least in situations where the landlord is an individual rather than a corporation.
(ii) Statutory Authority and Interpretation Guidelines
[44] The Board’s power to impose an administrative fine for illegal entry and other unlawful actions comes from s. 31(1)(d) of the RTA, which provides as follows:[2]31.(1) If the Board determines that a landlord, a superintendent or an agent of a landlord has done one or more of the activities set out in paragraphs 2 to 6 of subsection 29 (1), the Board may,
. . . .
(d) order that the landlord pay to the Board an administrative fine not exceeding the greater of $10,000 and the monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court;[3] [45] The Board’s Interpretation Guidelines provide that the purpose of an administrative fine is to encourage compliance with the RTA and to deter landlords from engaging in similar behaviour in the future. The Guidelines also state:This remedy is not normally imposed unless a landlord has shown a blatant disregard for the RTA and other remedies will not provide adequate deterrence and compliance. [46] The Guidelines state the following with respect to determining the quantum of a fine:In setting the amount of the fine, the Member may consider:. the nature and severity of the breach
. the effect of the breach on the tenant
. any other relevant factors. The amount of the fine should be commensurate with the breach. (iii) Other Contexts
(a) Criminal Context
[47] In the criminal context, a consideration of the ability to pay prior to imposing a fine is statutorily required by s. 734(2) of the Criminal Code, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46. However, the requirement existed at common law before s. 734(2) was enacted in 1995:[4] R. v. Noseworthy, 2000 NFCA 45, 192 Nfld. & P.E.I.R. 120, at paras. 9-12; R. v. Forbes (1984) 1984 CanLII 4134 (NB CA), 55 N.B.R. (2d) 24 (C.A.); R. v. Tracy (1992), 1992 CanLII 801 (BC CA), 12 B.C.A.C. 150, at para. 18. The primary concern with imposing fines on those who are unable to pay is the possibility of imprisonment in default: R. v. Topp, 2011 SCC 43, [2011] 3 S.C.R. 119, at para. 18. There is no risk of imprisonment associated with fines under the RTA, so this line of authority is of limited assistance.
[48] However, an ability to pay is also a relevant consideration where a court is considering making a restitution order pursuant to s. 738(1) of the Criminal Code, even though failure to pay a restitution order cannot result in imprisonment: R. v. Jeannotte, 2026 ONCA 79, 181 O.R. (3d) 289, at para. 25; R. v. Robertson, 2020 ONCA 367, at para. 8; R. v. Castro, 2010 ONCA 718, 102 O.R. (3d) 609, at para. 26; R. v. Popert, 2010 ONCA 89, 258 O.A.C. 163, at para. 40. Unlike with a fine, where ability to pay is a precondition to the making of the order, it is simply a factor to be considered together with other factors in determining whether a restitution order should be made: Castro, at para. 27.
[49] Once of the rationales for the requirement to inquire as to ability to pay prior to making a restitution order is a concern that an overly onerous restitution order will affect the accused’s prospects for rehabilitation, particularly where it would “ruin the accused financially”: R. v. Scherer (1984), 1984 CanLII 3594 (ON CA), 16 C.C.C. (3d) 30 (Ont. C.A.), at p. 38; Jeannotte, at para. 25; Robertson, at para. 8; Popert, at para. 30.
(b) Regulatory Context
[50] Section 57(3) of the Provincial Offences Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.33 (“POA”) provides that(3) Where a defendant is convicted of an offence, the court may make such inquiries, on oath or otherwise, of and concerning the defendant as it considers desirable, including the defendant’s economic circumstances, but the defendant shall not be compelled to answer. [51] Although the language of s. 57(3) is permissive, not mandatory, there is a body of caselaw holding that a court must make inquiries about an offender’s ability to pay prior to imposing a fine: Toronto (City) v. Kandiah, 2025 ONCJ 172, at para. 53; Ontario (Ministry of Natural Resources) v. Blais, [2015] O.J. No. 3760 (C.J.), at paras. 125-126; Real Estate Council of Ontario v. Wang, 2013 ONCJ 515, at para. 22; R. v. Kirk (c.o.b. B.A. Holdings), 2005 ONCJ 352, at para. 15; R. v. Wells (2003), 38 M.V.R. (4th) 93 (Ont. C.J.), at paras. 22-23; R. v. Henry Heyink Construction Ltd. (1999), 1999 CanLII 1254 (ON CA), 118 O.A.C. 261 (C.A.), at para.13; Czumak v. Etobicoke (City), [1994] O.J. No. 2247 (C.J.), at para. 56.
[52] Unlike a fine under the Criminal Code, an unpaid POA fine cannot result in imprisonment, although s. 69(2) provides that there may be other consequences such as suspension of a licence or permit and civil enforcement.
(c) Administrative Context
[53] An ability to pay is a relevant but not a determinative factor in the assessment of financial sanctions by the Ontario Securities Commission: Aziz v. Ontario (Securities Commission, Chief Executive Officer), 2024 ONSC 4691 (Div. Ct.), at para. 104; Re. Solar Income Fund Inc. (2023), 46 O.S.C.B. 512, at para. 70; Re Gold-Quest International (2015), 38 O.S.C.B. 273, at para. 13; Re Rezwealth Financial Services Inc. (2014), 2014 ONSEC 18 (CanLII), 37 O.S.C.B. 6731, at para. 70; Re York Rio Resources Inc. (2014), 2014 ONSEC 9 (CanLII), 37 O.S.C.B. 3422, at para. 81; Re Sabourin (2010), 2010 ONSEC 10 (CanLII), 33 O.S.C.B. 5299, at para. 60.
[54] Consideration of an ability to pay prior to the imposition of a monetary penalty also appears in other administrative proceedings: Re Leber, [2013] O.R.C.D. No. 31, at para. 23; Re Johnston, [2009] O.R.C.D. No. 44, at para. 57; 2017 LNICAO 10, at para. 65; Re Postrado, 2017 LNICAO 1, at para. 49.
(iv) The Ability to Pay Should be Considered by the Board
(a) Consistency
[55] In my view, there are several reasons why the ability to pay ought to be considered by the Landlord and Tenant Board in determining whether to impose an administrative fine as well as the quantum of any fine.
[56] First, as outlined above, doing so is consistent with the approach taken in other contexts.
(b) Ability to Pay and Deterrence
[57] Second, an inquiry into the ability to pay is necessary to ensure that the administrative penalty serves its purpose, which is to “deter landlords from engaging in similar activity in the future.” The connection between ability to pay and the deterrent effect of a monetary penalty was explained in Warman v. Lemire, 2014 FCA 18, [2015] 2 F.C.R. 117, at para. 102:The requirement that the Tribunal must consider the individual’s ability to pay can also be regarded as linked to deterrence: a person of limited means may be deterred from future breaches by a smaller penalty than a wealthier person. Similarly, it may take a larger penalty to deter a person who has been a repeat offender. In truth, the considerations relevant to sentencing may overlap with those governing the imposition of an administrative penalty since both are designed to prevent statutorily prohibited conduct. [58] The ability to pay is not only relevant to general deterrence, but to specific deterrence as well, as was explained in the context of monetary penalties imposed on corporations in Ontario (Ministry of Labour) v. New Mex Canada Inc., 2019 ONCA 30, 144 O.R. (3d) 673, at paras. 110-111:I will begin with specific deterrence. On the uncontested evidence before the sentencing justice, New Mex was financially precarious. It was barely surviving. Yet the fine that was imposed was more than twice the gross profit New Mex showed in its last profitable year. Even assuming that the principals of New Mex might not be inspired by the human tragedy of the death of a co-worker to take their OHSA [Occupational Health and Safety Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1] obligations more seriously, a much smaller fine than the one imposed would have been sufficient to drive that message home.
In my view, although the circumstances of the offender are crucial in identifying an effective specific deterrent sentence, they remain important in determining an effective general deterrent sentence, as well. The theory of general deterrence is that the sentence imposed and the relevant circumstances that support the sentence will become known to others and stand as a warning that the cost of the behaviour outweighs its benefits. Assuming the fine was $100,000, interested court watchers aware of the circumstances would not just see the $100,000 fine. They would see a $100,000 fine imposed on a closely held corporation operated by two individuals as a form of convenient business association for their modest 12-employee enterprise that, in a good year, might gross $100,000. The fine would send a message that corporate employers that violate OHSA obligations risk significantly burdensome, even existentially threatening fines. In my view, a $250,000 fine far exceeded what was required to send this deterrent message to employers.
See also Ontario (Workplace and Safety Insurance Board) v. Amazon Canada Fulfillment Services ULC, [2025] O.J. No. 5927 (S.C.J.), at para. 36. [59] These considerations are of particular importance in the landlord and tenant context. The circumstance of landlords who come before the Board vary greatly. Some may be large corporations owning numerous properties. Others may be pensioners renting out a basement flat in order to make ends meet. What may be a deterrent fine for the former could be financially ruinous for the latter. Conversely, a deterrent fine for the latter may be inconsequential to the former.
(c) Proportionality
[60] Third, the requirement of proportionality, which is the overriding principle in sentencing law, applies in the administrative context: R. v. Friesen, 2020 SCC 9, [2020] 1 S.C.R. 424, at para. 30; College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario v. Peirovy, 2018 ONCA 420, 143 O.R. (3d) 596, at para. 57; Canada (Commissioner of Competition) v. Chatr Wireless Inc., 2013 ONSC 5315, 288 C.R.R. (3d) 297, at para. 556; New Mex, at para. 102. One aspect of the proportionality principle is mentioned in the Board Interpretation Guidelines, which states that “The amount of the fine should be commensurate with the breach.” However, proportionality also requires that regard be had for the impact of the sanction on the individual: R. v. Hills, 2023 SCC 2, 477 D.L.R. (4th) 1, at para. 135.
[61] Depending on an individual’s circumstances, a large fine like the one imposed in this case can be crushing on an individual, which would offend the principle of proportionality. A fine that is financially devastating may not be commensurate with the breach. Conversely, the same fine may be inconsequential to a wealthy landlord, which would also result in the fine not being commensurate with the breach. It follows that the Board must have some knowledge of the individual’s circumstances to ensure that proportionality is respected.
(d) No Disadvantage
[62] Fourth, a requirement that the Board conduct some inquiry into an individual’s ability to pay would not impose any significant burden on the Board, as explained below. There is no disadvantage to making such inquiries.
(e) Contents of the Inquiry
[63] In most cases, all that will be required is a broad inquiry by the Board into the landlord’s financial circumstances, such as whether he or she is employed, his or her income, and a general description of assets and liabilities. A landlord is not required to provide such information, but if he fails to do so he cannot expect the Board to adjust what would otherwise be an appropriate fine to account for his circumstances. In some cases, the Board may already have sufficient information based on evidence adduced during the hearing.
[64] The ability to pay is one factor for the Board to consider, together with any other relevant factors. It will be for the Board to determine what weight to give this factor.
(f) Application to This Case
[65] It appears from the record before this court that the Member made no inquiries about the appellant’s ability to pay before imposing a substantial fine, nor did he invite any submissions from the appellant. As I have explained, some inquiry was required. As a result, the administrative fine must be set aside.
|